Comparing Crossfit To Calisthenics Street Workout

Posted On January 29, 2020

Crossfit and Calisthenics are diametrically opposed not only in technique but in the entire philosophy behind their teachings. Where crossfit sets out to do everything as quickly and as explosively as possible, calisthenics, having numerous elements of power, is much more focused on control and the ability to slow down, or in some cases, stop altogether the body’s natural tendency to submit to gravity.

In general, technique is greatly lacking in the crossfit community. Where the goal is to complete as many repetitions as possible in a given amount of time, there is, quite frankly, no time for technique. This is especially catastrophic when this philosophy is applied to heavy weights and to the relatively high-risk flagships borrowed from gymnastics.

When the body is already under a great deal of stress, speeding things up at the expense of technique is certain to lead to injury.

Both calisthenics and crossfit have flaws, but it’s the aim that matters

 

While it is true that the calisthenics and street workout community is not immune to such criticism, the goal of these disicplines is the eventual perfection movement. Whereas in crossfit, this is often pushed to a secondary seat in pursuit of ego, and encouraged by the rules of competition.

While calisthenics builds on movements it borrows, and through its entrepreneurial spirit, encouraged by the community and the competition, breathes new life into age forgotten skills; crossfit takes everything good in gymnastics and entirely purges it of value.

From ‘muscle ups’ to ‘handstands’, in crossfit the roots are forgotten and often disregarded, to create a sort of caricature of great arts in the appropriation of disicplines by will of its voracious appetite to consume, digest and shit out the principles governing correct form and injury prevention.

Calisthenics has a different attitude towards movement

 

Crossfit trivialises the difficulty of movement, by altering the movement rather than the athlete. By encouraging athletes that are clearly unconditioned to perform certain movements – despite the lack of fundamental strength body awareness and progression – crossfit makes it seem like anyone can do anything.

And sure enough, with enough swing, kick and hip thrusting the muscle up is doable for everyone- for only problem is that it’s no longer a muscle up.
Calisthenics finds itself in a position where few practitioners achieve even relatively basic movements.

In many senses this a good thing, and encourages progression and the building of the required strength. This also gives athletes an incredible sense of achievement when they complete a move- and they know they aren’t lying to themselves.

Have you tried calisthenics training?

 

Calisthenics is a fantastic way to change up your routine. The great thing about it is that it’s not about reps or sets or doing the same thing over and over again. Calisthenics is all about pushing the body to its limits by hitting various static and freestyle skills – while simultaneously burning calories and getting super strong! Get in touch with our Melbourne-based calisthenics personal trainers for more details!

Written by Vic

Melbourne-based Personal Trainer, Calisthenics Athlete and the Founder of Street Workout St Kilda. Super passionate about bodyweight training and the art of movement.
Related Posts
Best Protein Powder For Calisthenics – Whey Vs Plant-based

Best Protein Powder For Calisthenics – Whey Vs Plant-based

No matter what type of diet you follow, whether you are a carnivore, a vegetarian, or a vegan, your body needs protein to survive and carry out many of its functions - especially when training calisthenics. There are many protein-rich foods of both animal and plant...

read more
Human Flag – Calisthenics Static Hold Complete Guide

Human Flag – Calisthenics Static Hold Complete Guide

The human flag is an icon in calisthenics, and is perhaps one of the few unique static holds not found in gymnastics. There have been similar variations in pole dancing, however it’s likely that calisthenics founded this isometric hold. In calisthenics the human flag...

read more
Street Workout For Beginners

Street Workout For Beginners

What is Street Workout?Street workout is an emerging fitness discipline; forged in the fumes of chaos. It hails from Eastern Europe and Russia, where street workout stations are as commonplace as alcohol selling kiosks. Slavs embraced this style of workout due to the...

read more
How To Lose Weight Fast Without Cardio

How To Lose Weight Fast Without Cardio

Losing fat is a tricky business. Fat is at the end of the day the body’s energy storage. The very process of storing fat is embedded into every human by evolution, and has been integral to our survival through millennia. That is until very recently. Never in human...

read more
Calisthenics Australia – From Dance to Street Workout

Calisthenics Australia – From Dance to Street Workout

Calisthenics Australia is the governing body behind what has traditionally been a sport of dance - incorporating elements of rhythmic gymnastics, performing arts and costumes. This type of calisthenics is female dominated, unsurprisingly. It has been around for some...

read more
handstand volcano bali blog
your trainer